I'm not law enforcement or sportsman etc.
It also is my first and only holster, so I can't compare it to anything else. With that said.
This holster keeps my gun from falling out.
It is very comfortable on my hip. I use the belt loop and not the paddle version. I literally have it on my hip all day around my house and I don't get any pressure marks on my hip, weight seems evenly distributed. I've ran around with it hung upside down and it holds it nicely. The one touch removal button is awesome. I'd definitely recommend it for anybody. it feels natural as I draw the gun and my finger is already on the safety.